I sometimes wonder where on earth do the Government get their ideas about education in the UK? At a recent NUT meeting (yes I have a spy in there), teachers discussed striking over proposals put forward by ministers to change the A-level system (Post-16.) Wait what is this? Teachers are going to strike over concerns that proposals will damage student’s lives? This is odd, we thought teachers only strike for a pay rise, less hours, more holidays and more time at the beach. Funny how the media never really offers this side of the story but continues to spout the government’s rhetoric that teacher’s striking only damages their reputation, when in fact teacher’s are sacrificing their pay for the benefit of the future of students.

The proposal that I would like to focus on-for there are many complex subject specific ones- is the idea that A levels should be linear. Not content with removing January exams, the government wishes to remove AS exams as well, thus ensuring students a completely horrendous second year at college. Ministers such as dear old Mr Gove, feel that currently exams are easy as they allow students to revise for them, complete them at the end of the year and then forget about them.

The irony of this is that even when there were mid-year exams, students still found them difficult. This is because A-levels are not easy, they were not and are not in need of such drastic reform. The vast majority of students would agree with this statement as the work needed to achieve top grades at A-level is immense. Perhaps there are some subjects where reform is needed but to spread such an oppressive blanket over all is unacceptable. A change to a linear system would heap more pressure on students who have just made the jump from GCSE to A levels and so would result in lower grades, lower numbers of people entering into top universities and less people becoming qualified for higher wage jobs. It seems as if the government can’t create more jobs so they simply want to reduce the demand for them. 

The point about students forgetting their subject material after exams is also flawed. Firstly, many subjects such as Government & Politics require students to use knowledge learnt at AS in A2 exams. Secondly, subjects such as Maths and English in which a student’s skills are developed rather than actual knowledge, do not require memorising but refining and building upon skills. Thirdly, the intense revision students do to prepare for exams means they are unlikely to forget what they learnt in a hurry. Fourthly, merely having to remember subject knowledge for two years is no guarantee that students will go on to remember it for a longer period of time as they can simply forget what they learnt after two years, so the only thing changing to a linear format would do is delay the inevitable. Fifthly, when did memorising become the way to determine intelligence? All this will do is force teachers to teach completely to the exam rather than give students an enriching experience. 

The fact there is five arguments against this proposal is surely proof that it is a wrong move. The arguments for changing A levels to a linear exam are weak and invalid. You may as well abolish all exams in secondary school and expect students to remember everything from year 7 to year 11. This is what happens when the views of students are not even considered as the people in charge act as if they know what is best for us but in reality, they simply do not. Perhaps the Department Of Education should consider hiring some actual students to help them make their decisions. 

Until next time,

A Worried Student

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “If It Ain’t Broke, Don’t Fix It!

  1. I have absolutely no idea how the education system works in the UK, other than the little bits I’ve received in french class over the past 3-4 years. We have a lot of striking go on over here in the U.S. these past few years as well.

    Like

    • Haha its the different terms used betwern countries like the UK and the US that make it so confusing! We have primary school which is from ages 5-11.
      Then 11-16 is secondary and thereafter college is post 16 which normally lasts 2 years.
      Finally, university! Which lasts three to four years depending on your degree and then you go into work or a postgraduate. Yes, too much learning!

      It seems like education is being mishandled worldwide.

      Like

      • Ahhh I see! So your primary school is like our elementary school which is typically 6-11. Then there’s middle-school which is 11-13/14. After middle school there’s high school which is 13/14-18. In the UK and US university is pretty much the same, but we call it college. Although there’s so many other types of school as well like home schooling, un-schooling, online school, hybrid, etc.

        I think the education system varies so dramatically which is why it fails in so many ways. The rules are supposed to be for all schools but it’s so different even within miles if each other and in the same areas…

        Like

      • And thank you for that explanation, now I.finally get the US system!
        Yes you call it college (I think I have perfected the American accent for this one word!)
        Yes in the US it must be even more difficult due to there obviously being much more students and schools. In the UK its a bit easier, if only the government listened to those working in education!

        Like

      • oh I should also add that we have Pre-K (Preschool) which is typically age 4. Then Kindergarten which is age 5 and then they move onto the elementary schools. Although Pre-K isn’t really required but it’s not harmful either. A lot of parents keep their kids home for Pre-K and just teach them themselves, but if parents work it’s a great educational addition to daycare.

        I think the UK has it much more simpler, and quite frankly probably better than the US. We have so many issues and variances that make it difficult.

        Like

      • Aah so we call Pre-K playgroup which I didn’t attend as I just cried :/
        Kindergarten is nursery, aah those blissful carefree times! Yes my brain still remembers snatches of those moments lol

        Hmm yes but if these alarmingly rapid and nonsensical changes take place in the UK, then the two systems may begin to rival each other in terms of craziness!

        Like

      • haha when I was in kindergarten I had a crush on this boy in my class. He rode my bus so I would always try to sit by him on the bus or in class. He didn’t like me very much, he tried avoiding me at all costs!

        I can only imagine what’s going to happen. Hopefully the teacher strike makes a difference!

        Like

Have something to add or a question to ask? Now is the time!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s